Effectiveness of Nursing Intervention on Knowledge and
Practice of Feeding Among Caregivers of Cerebral Palsy Children.
Amirtha Lourdu Mary. I.
College of Nursing, Sri Ramakrishna Institute of
Paramedical sciences, Siddhapudur, Coimbatore-44
E-mail:
ABSTRACT:
Introduction
Feeding and eating are important activities that allow
individuals to maintain adequate growth in the children with cerebral palsy.
They are at risk because of oral, pharyngeal or esophageal dysphagia.
oral motor dysfunction (OMD), communication
difficulties that may deteriorate their health status. Focusing on the
nutritional aspects may help them to maintain their health status. So the
investigator was interested to conduct a research study to bring awareness
among care-givers.
Material and
methods:
A quasi experimental non equivalent control group
design was adopted for this study. There
were 30 caregivers, 15 in each control and experimental groups were selected.
Through non probability purposive sampling technique the samples were selected
and assessed by means of a structured questionnaire and observation check
list. Health education cum demonstration
on feeding practice of cerebral palsy children was given to the experimental
group. The data was analyzed by means of descriptive and inferential
statistics.
Results and
findings:
The care-givers of CP children had moderately adequate
knowledge and feeding practice during the pre-test. The experimental group
gained more knowledge score than the control group of caregivers in the
post-test. This is proved by‘t’ test (n = 30) = 16.22 (p<0.01). The health education and demonstration
on feeding practices was found to be effective and the care-givers improved
their feeding practice and reduced their feeding difficulties and problems to
their children.
Conclusion:
Research hypothesis stated was accepted. It was
concluded that there is a need to improve the knowledge and practice of feeding
the cerebral palsy children among the care-givers.
KEY WORDS: Care-giver, Cerebral
palsy children, feeding practices, health education.
INTRODUCTION:
Feeding problems are
very common in children with cerebral palsy as 30 to 80 percent of disabled
individuals feed with difficulty. The incidence of malnutrition in individuals
with cerebral palsy is a combination of factors, which directly or indirectly
result in reduced food and nutrient intake. Feeding problems are usually
complicated by the lack of awareness of parents about disease and the incidence
of malnutrition in individuals with cerebral palsy.
The main reasons for
lack of awareness in parents were illiteracy, misconception about disease and
associated complications of cerebral palsy. (Motion, Northstone, 2002).
Objectives:
1.
Assess the care
givers existing knowledge on feeding of cerebral palsy children among
experimental and control group.
2.
Assess the
practice of feeding of cerebral palsy children among caregivers of both
experimental and control groups.
3.
Assess the care
givers knowledge on feeding of cerebral palsy children after nursing
intervention in the experimental group.
4.
Compare the
knowledge scores of both experimental and control groups of caregivers on
feeding of cerebral palsy children.
5.
Find out the
effectiveness of nursing intervention on feeding practices of cerebral palsy
children among caregivers in experimental group.
6.
Associate the
selected demographic characteristics of caregivers and cerebral palsy child
with their knowledge on feeding practice in both groups.
Hypothesis
:-
H1 - There
is a significant improvement in knowledge on feeding among caregivers who
received nursing intervention, than those who did not receive nursing
intervention.
Methodology
Research
design:
Quasi experimental non equivalent
control group design without use of randomization.
Variables
under the Study:
Individual teaching cum demonstration on feeding is
independent variable. Caregiver’s knowledge and practice on feeding of cerebral
palsy children are dependent variables.
Setting:
The study was conducted at Amrit
centre for special needs, Mettupalayam road,
Coimbatore, and Ashirwad The
Coimbatore spastic trust, R.S. Puram, Coimbatore.
Population:
All care givers of cerebral palsy children with feeding
difficulty.
Sample size:
The sample size for the study consists of 30 cerebral
palsy children and their caregivers.
Among them, 15 from Amrit center was assigned
to experimental group and 15 from Ashirwaad center
was assigned to control group.
Sampling
technique:
Non probability Purposive sampling technique was
adopted for the present study.
Criteria for sample selection:
Inclusion criteria:
1. Caregivers who are involved in feeding of cerebral
palsy children.
2. Child age ranging from 6 – 12 years who are having
cerebral palsy
Exclusion criteria:
1. Cerebral palsy children who have medical problems.
2. Children with associated facial anomaly. e.g. cleft lip and palate.
3. Care givers who have already participated in similar
kind of study.
Development
and Description of the tool for data collection:
The tool was developed by the researcher.
Teaching
Module:
A planned individual teaching module prepared regarding
feeding of cerebral palsy children which includes causes for cerebral palsy, feeding problems, type of food, quantity, quality,
and consistency of food, duration and
frequency of feed, management of feeding difficulties like position, chewing,
drooling, choking, utensils used for feeding, and hygienic practices.
Description
of tool:
Section A: Demographic profile of the care giver and
cerebral palsy child.
Section B: Questionnaire on assessing the knowledge on feeding.
Section C: Observation checklist to assess the feeding
practice.
Section A:
Caregiver’s demographic profile
include type of marriage, number of children, family type, family
history of cerebral palsy, and source of information. Child’s demography
includes age of the child, sex, weight and birth order
of the affected child.
Section B:
Structured questionnaire consisting of 30 closed ended
questions with multiple choice answers on various aspects on feeding of
cerebral palsy child. Each right answer
was assigned the score of one and wrong answer zero. The maximum score possible was 30 and the
minimum score was zero. Higher the score greater the knowledge on feeding of
cerebral palsy children.
Section C:
Observational checklist to evaluate
the feeding practice of caregivers. The checklist contains position of the child
during feeding, food item, frequency of feeding, consistency of food, duration of the
feeding, and care of the child after feeding, hygienic practices, management of
feeding problems and feeding difficulties.
Plan for data
analysis:
The obtained data from the subjects were computed with
appropriate descriptive and inferential statistical analysis to test the
hypothesis and to achieve the set objectives. To compare the effectiveness of
nursing intervention,‘t’ test was used. 'Chi' square was used to assess the
association between selected demographic variables with the knowledge scores of
the caregivers in both groups.
RESULTS:
In Experimental group regarding the type of marriage,
all 15 caregivers (100%) got non consanguineous marriage. Majority of caregivers (86.67%) two children
and only 2 care givers (13.33%) have only one child. Considering family type 6
care givers (40%) are in joint family and care givers (60%) are in nuclear
family.
Table 1: Comparison of pre test
knowledge scores of care givers on experimental group and control group.
|
Group |
Mean |
Standard
deviation |
Independent
't' value |
|
Experimental Pre test |
13.20 |
1.42 |
1.45 (NS) |
|
Control Pre test |
14.53 |
1.28 |
NS-Not significant
In the above table 1 the ’t’
value 1.45 for the mean difference in the pretest knowledge scores of care
givers between experimental and control group is not significant. Hence,
the homogeneity is maintained in the knowledge score of the care givers between
experimental and control group.
Table 2: Comparison of post test knowledge scores of care givers between
experimental and control groups.
|
Group |
Mean |
Standard
deviation |
Independent
't' value |
|
Experimental post test |
24 |
1.73 |
16.22** |
|
Control post test |
14.6 |
1.5 |
** - p < 0.01
In the above table 2 the’t’
value 16.22 for the mean difference in the post test knowledge score of the
care giver on feeding practice of the control and experimental group is
significant (P<0.01).
The mean post test knowledge scores of the care givers
in the experimental and control group on feeding practice of cerebral palsy
children were 24 and 14.6 respectively of reveals
that the nursing intervention is effective in enhancing the knowledge of the
care giver on feeding practice. Hence the proposed alternative H1 hypothesis
is accepted
Table 3:
Distribution of experimental and control groups of care givers on feeding
practice of cerebral palsy children
N = 15
|
S. No. |
Particulars |
Control
group |
Experimental
group |
||||||
|
Pre Observation. |
Post
observation |
Pre-observation |
Post-observation |
||||||
|
N |
% |
N |
% |
N |
% |
N |
% |
||
|
1. |
Position Sitting Upright Semi sitting Sitting leaning forward Lying |
2 7 6 - |
13.33 46.67 40.00 - |
2 6 7 - |
13.33 40.00 46.67 - |
3 8 4 - |
20.00 53.33 26.67 - |
13 - 2 - |
86.67 - 13.33 - |
|
2. |
Food items Pulses and cereals Pulses and meat Pulses, cereals, meat, vegetables and fruits |
11 - 4 |
73.33 - 26 |
10 - 5 |
66.67 - 33.33 |
10 - 5 |
66.67 - 33.33 |
2 - 13 |
13.33 - 86.67 |
|
3. |
Frequency
of feeding Four times Five times Six times Three times |
3 3 - 9 |
20.00 20.00 - 60.00 |
3 3 - 9 |
20.00 20.00 - 60.00 |
4 3 - 8 |
26.67 20.00 - 53.33 |
- 14 - 1 |
- 93.33 - 6.67 |
|
4. |
Consistency of food items Liquid Semi solid Solid Normal |
- 7 - 8 |
- 46.67 - 53.33 |
- 8 - 7 |
- 53.33 - 46.67 |
- 8 - 7 |
- 53.33 - 46.67 |
- 12 - 3 |
- 80.00 - 20.00 |
|
5. |
Duration of feeding 10 minutes 10 - 15 minutes 20 minutes More than 30 minutes |
- 5 8 2 |
- 33.33 53.33 13.33 |
- 6 7 2 |
- 40.00 46.67 13.33 |
- 6 7 2 |
- 40.00 46.67 13.33 |
- 1 2 12 |
- 6.67 13.33 80.00 |
|
6. |
After care of the child Repositioning Burping Cleaning the mouth Cleaning the utensils |
7 4 11 12 |
46.67 26.67 73.33 80 |
6 5 12 11 |
40.00 33.33 80.00 73.33 |
8 3 10 10 |
53.33 20.00 66.67 66.67 |
14 13 15 15 |
93.33 86.67 100.00 100.00 |
|
7. |
Hygienic practices Hand washing Nail clean Utensil washing |
10 8 7 |
66.67 53.33 46.67 |
10 8 7 |
66.67 53.33 46.67 |
10 8 7 |
66.67 53.33 46.67 |
15 13 13 |
100.00 86.67 86.67 |
|
8. |
Feeding difficulty Chewing Swallowing Regurgitation Drooling |
2 6 1 5 |
13.33 40.00 6.67 33.33 |
2 6 1 5 |
13.33 40.00 6.67 33.33 |
2 5 2 6 |
13.33 33.33 13.33 40.00 |
- 2 - 2 |
- 13.33 - 13.33 |
|
9. |
Feeding problems Apnoea Aspiration Coughing and chocking Cyanosis and tachypnea |
- 4 4 - |
- 26.67 26.67 - |
- 4 4 - |
- 26.67 26.67 - |
- 3 4 - |
- 20.00 26.67 - |
- - 1 - |
- - 6.67 - |
The table (3) represents the observation scores among
control and experimental group of caregivers on feeding practice of cerebral
palsy children. With regard to position of the child during feeding shows that
86.67% were followed sitting upright position, the same 86.67% of children were
taking pulses, cereals, meat, vegetables and fruits in their food, 93.33% were taking food 5 times a day, and
80% of children were taking normal food.
Out of 15
children, 12(80%) were taking food for more than 30 minutes, All the children
cleaned mouth and utensils, all followed hygienic practices like hand washing,
swallowing difficulty and drooling faced by 13.33% of children, and other
feeding problems like coughing and choking experienced by 6.67% of children.
DISCUSSION:
Comparison of pre test knowledge scores of control and experimental group of
caregivers on feeding of cerebral palsy children reveal that there is no
significant difference of knowledge among both groups on feeding of cerebral
palsy children. Hence, the homogeneity
is maintained. Comparison of post test knowledge score of care givers of both
control and experimental group on feeding of cerebral palsy children, the‘t’ value of 16.22 is statistically significant at 0.01
level. The interventional group who
received health education cum demonstration was scored more than control group
of caregivers. The effectiveness of
Health education was documented.
Distribution of caregivers of control and experimental
groups according to the pre and post test scores of observation checklist
revealed that though
the observations are not statistically proved, still there is lot of
improvements in areas of feeding practice and reduction in problems during
feeding.
Considering the position during pretest 20% were
followed upright position during feeding their child, after intervention 86.67%
were maintained upright in post test of the experimental group.In
after care of the child, repositioning was followed by 53.33% of caregivers in
the pre test. In the post test 93.33%
were followed. After feeding 20% only done burping to their
children in pre test. In the post
test 86.67% had
done the burping in experimental group. In reduction of feeding difficulty, 33.33% had
swallowing difficulty in prestest, it was reduced as 13.33% in post test. During pre test 13.33% were got regurgition in pretest, In the post test it was nil. And drooling also reduced in some extend in the experimental group. Among feeding problems,
20% of aspiration in pretest was reduced as nil in post test of experimental
group. And experience of coughing and choking reduced
from 26.67% to 6.67% in post test.
Recommendations:
·
A similar study
can be conducted with large sample.
·
A study can be
done by using different instruction technology.
·
A comparative
study can be conducted to assess the feeding problem and care needed between
cerebral palsy children and children affected with other disabilities.
·
A study can be
conducted as a long term study on nutritional status and growth of cerebral
palsy children.
Limitations:
·
The researcher
could not generalize the study findings as the sample size was small.
·
Observation of
feeding practice of cerebral palsy children could not be done in their home
setup.
REFERENCES:
1.
Florence Yossem.,(1998).
Clinical Management of feeding disorder.(1st ed.).
Newton: Butterworth-Heinemann.
2.
Nancie R Finnie. (1997). Handling the Young child with Cerebral Palsy at Home. (3rd
ed.). Johannesburg: Butter worth Heinemann.
3.
Aota, (2007). Specialized Knowledge and Skills in
Feeding, Eating, and Swallowing for Occupational Therapy Practice. The
American Journal of Occupational Therapy, Vol: 61, 686-697.
4.
Fung EB, Samson
and Samson-Fang L, (2002). Feeding Dysfunction is Associated with Poor Growth
and Health Status in Children with Cerebral Palsy. Journal of American Dietetic Association. Vol:
83, 47-53.
5.
Gangil A (2001).
Feeding difficulties in Children with Cerebral Palsy to assess the
parental awarenesss. Available from
www.indianpediatrics.net/aug2001/aug 839-846.htm
6.
Larnert G and Ekberg O (1995). Positioning improves the oral and pharyngeal
Swallowing function in children with cerebral palsy. Acta Paediatr 84, 689-692.
7.
Veness C,
Reilly S. (2008). Meal time
Interaction Patterns Between Young Children with
Cerebral Palsy and their Mothers:
Characteristics and relationship to feeding impairment. Available from www/ feeding.in / cpchild.
Received on 30.08.2011 Modified
on 12.09.2011
Accepted
on 09.11.2011 ©
A&V Publication all right reserved
Asian J. Nur. Edu. and Research 1(4): Oct-Dec. 2011;
Page 109-112